Harle! We played pirate music, and it was good. After Dark had a sponsor, and it was not good. The universe once again establishes equilibrium.

1. Pirates R Us – KYAR Pirate Radio (3:55)
2. Brine & Bastards – The Pilot (2:11)
3. Jollyship The Whiz Bang – Roving (3:21)
4. Captain Dan and the Scurvy Crew – Hook It Up (3:23)
5. Abney Park – Airship Pirate (4:02)
6. Bone Island Buccaneers – Blow the Man Down (2:51)
7. Lost Boys – Scoundrels (3:39)
8. Captain Bogg & Salty – Bunnyjacks (3:24)
9. Hucklescary Finn – We Were Tired of Living on the Ground (2:57)
10. Alestorm – Leviathan (5:56)
11. Pirates Charles – Kylg’rath’ya (7:48)
12. Sforzando – Lydia Street Jig (1:44)
13. Mike Mennard – Gallows Tree (0:27)
14. Ben Gunn Society – Hey, Monkey! (1:46)
15. Mizzen – Pirate Magic Trilogy Part 1 (8:05)
16. Dan Zanes – All For Me Grog (2:42)
17. Billy Knight – Dead Men Tell No Tales (4:41)
18. Pirates R Us – Lobster Manor (Sorry About the Tickets) (2:58)
19. Captain Darby O’Bill And His Matees Three – Marina, The Lovely Mermaid (5:17)
20. Captain Bogg & Salty – Drunken Sailor (3:13)
21. Mizzen – Love Chum (3:04)
22. Dreadnoughts – Mary, the One-Eyed Prostitute, Who Fought the Colossal Squid and Saved Us from Certain Death on the High Seas, God Rest Her One-Eyed Soul (5:07)
23. Monsterpop – Beyond the Seven Seas (2:24)
24. Sunken Chest – Sunken Chest (3:21)
25. Skip Henderson – The Mermaid (3:11)
26. Dead Men’s Tales – Sailor’s Waltz (3:54)
27. That Damned Band – Bloodthirsty! (5:17)
28. Rustmonster – Still A’ Smilin (short) (3:31)

After Dark:

29. Salty Dick (Richard Docker, PhD) – The Red Flag (2:19)
30. Brine & Bastards – F.T.W. (3:03)
31. Dennis Gilmore – Four Whores from Baltimore (4:14)
32. Jolly Rogers – The Ladies All Loved Me (live) (7:43)
33. Bilge Pumps – Pirate Blues (4:44)
34. Alaskan Pirate & His Salty Seamen – Pirate’s Fancy (2:43)
35. Pirates Charles – MACCSB (steez 2) (2:44)
36. Captain Dan and the Scurvy Crew – Sea Weeds (3:40)
37. Dreadnoughts – Boneyard (3:32)
38. Brigands – Rummer, the Rumrunner (4:13)
39. Valparaiso Mens Chorus – Cape Cod Girls (1:57)
40. Whiskey Bards – Maid of Amsterdam (3:24)
41. Pirates Charles – Talderoy (live) (5:00)
42. Scurvy Pirates – Fishpie (1:50)
43. Captain Dan and the Scurvy Crew – Ladies In Scarlet (3:00)
44. Roving Tars – Captain Matheson (3:08)